DM's Tips, Rules & Mechanics

Using Skill Points in 5E Dungeons & Dragons

How to use skill points instead of proficiencies in 5E?

One of the gripes I often see players and DMs have with fifth edition D&D has to do with the game’s very simple – and quite rigid – skill system.

In this post, I’ll describe how you can replace 5E’s skill proficiency system with Skill Points – yeah, those nifty little things you may remember from earlier editions of Dungeons & Dragons!

Of all the house rules I have exposed my patient players to over the years, this rule is the most popular by far. My players love it because it is optional, has minimal effect on game balance, and expands character options without actually changing the game.

Before we get started, consider signing up for our mailing list and following Eventyr Games on Twitter or Facebook to receive updates about similar content in the future!

The Issue with Skill Proficiencies

First off, why would you even want to change the way skills work in 5E?

One of the joys of creating a D&D character is figuring out what the character is good at: the character’s skills. In 5th edition, this is done at 1st level by choosing your character’s skill proficiencies – which skills you can add your character’s proficiency bonus to.

The best thing about this system is its simplicity: if your character is good at something, you add its proficiency bonus – which only changes at levels 5, 9, 13 and 17 – to that skill check.

Simple, elegant, easy.

Simplicity comes at a cost, however – less customization and character diversity. In earlier editions of D&D (and systems such as Pathfinder), you would spend Skill Points each level, choosing which skills to progress in.

This allowed a character to not only be better at some skills than others (something that is only possible with the Expertise-feature in 5E), but also to easily pick up new skills (something that can be done during downtime, or with feats, class features, and items in 5E).

In our games, we’ve found that while fifth edition’s simple skill system served us well in the start, allowing especially newer players to easily get a grasp on things, the system eventually felt a bit too constrained. Several of my players expressed dissatisfaction with not being able to pick up new skills as they gained levels, or asked if it would be possible to ‘split’ proficiencies among several skills, so they could gain more skill diversity.

So, I began looking for a solution. But not just any solution. Since some of my other players had no issue with the skill proficiency system and preferred to stick with it, I had to find a solution that was not only simple and easy to implement, but also balanced against the existing system, so players could opt in or out as they preferred.

Converting Skill Proficiencies to Skill Points

Enter the Skill Points Conversion Table.

If you’re not a fan of tables, you can also use the following formula of conversion:
Skill Points (rounded down) = ((Proficiencies/4) x (Level – 1)) + (2 x Proficiencies)
Yeah, I prefer the table too – you can download it at the bottom of this post.

Just look at this beauty! I know, I know, at first glance it doesn’t look simple at all – but it truly is, trust me.

What we do with this table is convert the number of skill proficiencies a character would have into Skill Points instead.

Simply find your character’s total number of proficiencies on the top row (a number between 4 and 18), and go down that column until you find your character’s level: you now know your character’s total Skill Points.

At 1st level and every level after that, you then assign these Skill Points to your character’s different skills, and voíla – you’re now using Skill Points instead of skill proficiencies.

This means that everything else about the game stays the same – what proficiencies characters get from what races, classes, features, etc. – but instead of directly assigning these proficiencies, you instead note the total number of proficiencies your character has, and then consult the table to see how many Skill Points it has instead.

Because this system changes nothing about everything else in the game, you can have half the players at the table use Skill Points, while the other half continues using skill proficiencies. Yay!

Examples

Here’s a few quick examples of how the conversion works:

  • Dwarf Fighter. A dwarf fighter (+2 skill proficiencies) with the soldier background (+2 skill proficiencies) has 4 skill proficiencies. This means 8 Skill Points at 1st level + 1 Skill Point each level after that. If the fighter chooses the Purple Dragon Knight subclass, they gain another skill proficiency at 7th level, which bumps their total skill proficiencies up to 5 – and increases their Skill Points at 7th level from 14 to 18.
  • Half-elf Rogue/Bard. A half-elf (+2 skill proficiencies) rogue (+4 skill proficiencies) with the criminal background (+2 skill proficiencies) has 8 skill proficiencies. This means 16 skill points at 1st level + 2 skill points each level after that. However, if the rogue immediately multiclasses to become a Lore Bard, they can pick up another skill proficiency from multiclassing plus another 3 from the Lore Bard’s 3rd level feature – which gives them a total of 12 skill proficiencies – or a whopping 33 skill points at 4th level!

Ground Rules

While the system is fairly simple and the conversion is straightforward, there’s a few ground rules that needs to be established:

  • Skill Point Cap. The number of Skill Points assigned to a specific skill can’t exceed your proficiency bonus (which means a maximum of 2 at 1st level, 3 at 5th level, 4 at 9th level, and so on).
  • Saving Skill Points. You can ‘save’ Skill Points until you decide which skill you want to spend them on, or until the cap (see ‘Skill Point Cap’) on maximum Skill Points per skill increases with your proficiency bonus. (It’s helpful to keep track of total skill points and spent skill points somewhere on your character sheet).
  • Expertise. As usual, your bonus (from proficiency or Skill Points) in a skill you have Expertise in is doubled.
  • Reliable Talent. Reliable Talent (and similar features) applies only to skills that you have assigned the maximum amount of Skill Points to (see ‘Skill Point Cap’).
  • Jack-of-All-Trades. Jack-of-all-Trades (and similar features) allows you to add half your proficiency bonus, rounded down, to any skill check you make that doesn’t already include your proficiency bonus, or the difference between the two, if the number of skill points assigned to the skill is less than half your proficiency bonus, rounded down.

Optional Rules

When using Skill Points, there’s also some additional rules that the DM can enforce, at their discretion:

  • Limited Skills. You can only assign Skill Points to skills that are on your class list, or that you would have gained proficiency in through other means. (I personally don’t enforce this rule, as I don’t think barring certain classes from certain skills makes the game more fun – but hey, you may feel differently).
  • Reassigning Skill Points. You can reassign one already assigned Skill Point every time you level up. This rule allows characters to ‘unlearn’ certain skills and reinvest in other skills, which seems both realistic and allows characters to progress and adapt faster.
  • Bonus Skill Points. You gain a flat bonus to your total Skill Points equal to your Intelligence Modifier. Intelligence is widely regarded as one of the weaker ability scores in the game. Giving characters a bonus to Skill Points (as opposed to full Skill Proficiencies, which would be too strong) equal to their Intelligence Modifier helps make Intelligence more attractive.

Game Balance

Alright, so I’ve been touting this as a houserule that has nearly no effect on the balance of the game, and which can be employed selectively – with some players using Skill Points, while others continue to use skill proficiencies. But is that really true?

Well, let’s be honest – of course a character won’t ever become weaker because its using Skill Points.

First off, Skill Points are more versatile, and versatility is never a drawback. Simply having access to more different skills can be a strength.

Second, characters receive Skill Points gradually, which means that a 3rd level character who would normally have 4 proficiencies and thus a combined skill bonus of +8 (four skills with a +2 bonus), would have a combined skill bonus of +10 (which could be five skills with a +2 bonus, ten skills with a +1 bonus, or anything in between) when using Skill Points instead.

I would argue, however, that this only makes a character using Skill Points marginally stronger, and only in specific situations. As long as each player has the choice of whether they want to use Skill Points or not, I think this system is more than fair, even if some players opt out – there’s been no issues at my tables, at least.

Even if problems should arise, reverting back to skill proficiencies, or allowing a player who changes their mind to use Skill Points instead, can be done very quickly and without issues.

You can also choose to only let characters get new skill points when their proficiency would increase (levels 5, 9, 13, and 17), although I feel this somewhat defeats the purpose of Skill Points. But whatever you think works best at your table – that’s what you should do.

Drawbacks

So what are the drawbacks of using Skill Points instead of skill proficiencies?

The only real drawback is added complexity.

First off, there’s a bit more thinking and calculations to do each level (“eh, how many skill points do I have this level? Let me check out the table…”).

Second, you have to have different numbers written down for each skill, instead of just noting which skills your character is proficient in and what your proficiency bonus is. This means that players may have to consult their sheets more frequently while playing.

Overall, I think that this added complexity is a relatively minor drawback, but it’s still probably best to reserve this system for more experienced players. Again, it’s totally possible to allow veteran players to experiment with using Skill Points, while newer players at the table keep using skill proficiencies until they feel comfortable adding in more complexity.

Conclusion

You can download a cheatsheet with the Skill Points table and the various rules for using Skill Points here:

So, what do you think about these rules for converting skill proficiencies into Skill Points? Are you going to try them out? Do you see any room for improvement? Let me know in the comments below! And, don’t forget to sign up for our mailing list and follow Eventyr Games on Twitter or Facebook to receive updates about similar content in the future.

J. A. Valeur

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s